Problems in Physics – Kapitza

This one I have been searching for a while. I had read reference to this work in some book (which I don’t remember now),  and ever since was trying to find it. Luckily today I landed on a page which had link to this book, thanks to Alex for putting up this book.

The ‘book’ seems to be is a part of a larger book, maybe selected/complete works Collected Papers of of P. L. Kapitza last chapter (32) of last volume (4). Also see comment of Alex). I do not know the original source. It has but 19 pages and there are 224 problems, and no solutions. But don’t be fooled by the number of pages. These are some of the most interesting and difficult problems you will encounter, and you will perhaps need all your wits to get through them. But they are fun, and you will enjoy doing them, even if some are very difficult. So don’t be disheartened if, you cannot solve them at all. But they will certainly set you thinking for sure.

This is what Kapitza writes about them:

The problems published in this collection were compiled by me for students of the Moscow Physical-Technical Institute, where I taught a course in general physics in 1947-1949. The collection also includes problems given at examinations for postgraduate studies at the Institute of Physical Problems at the USSR Academy of Sciences.

And on the characteristics of the problems:

I strove to achieve this end by formulating the majority of questions in the following manner. A small problem is presented, and the student, using the known laws of physics, must analyse and describe quantitatively the natural phenomenon involved. These natural phenomena were selected in terms of their scientific or practical interest within the scope of the students’ level of knowledge.

A characteristic feature of our problems is that they have no definite answer because the student is allowed to proceed further and further with the analysis of the problem posed, depending on his own abilities and inclinations.

Most of the problems have another distinctive trait. They do not contain numerical values of physical constants or parameters, and the student has to choose them personally.

And on how they were conducted

In the examinations, the students were always given complete freedom to use literature for solving the problems. Usually a few (up to 5) problems were given per examination, so as to enable the students to choose 23 of them. Thus, the inclinations of a student could be gauged from his selection of problems. For postgraduate examinations, new and more complex problems were prepared; in these cases, however, the student was allowed not only use of literature but also freedom to seek advice. Indeed, the scientist must cultivate the skill of using the advice of others, apart from learning the use of literature. In scientific work, discussions and consultations with colleagues and instructors are essential for success; this) however, requires a proper training from the very beginning of the studies.

We usually allowed about one hour for the solution of each problem. All problems have to be solved in writing, but the capabilities and character of the student become evident mostly 1n the course of a verbal discussion of the written text.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in books, physics, problem books, science and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Problems in Physics – Kapitza

  1. Alex says:

    Yeah, the problems I have are a scan from the final chapter from “Collected Papers of P.L. Kapitza” There were no solutions available. I thought the problems should be made more available, as they are quite the treasure.

  2. Chhatrasal Rathore says:

    Dear Damitr I downloaded some books authored by Landau and Liftshitz from MIR Publishers from Net. I don’t know how can I send these books for your site.     Regards   Yours sincerely Chhatrasal

    ________________________________

    • damitr says:

      Which are these books? Are they the 10 Volume Landua-Lifshitz Course in Theoretical Physics, and they were not published my Mir, afaik? You may see some of them already posted here, see in the comments Anu has posted some links.

      D

      • MirBooksLover says:

        Dear Readers:
        Just for information, The course of Theoretical Physics-Landau and Lifshitz was publiched in 10 volumes by Mir Publisher but in the french language under the name (cours de physique théorique, L. Landau et E. Lifchitz, Mir, Moscou). According to Wiki. french, Landau was not participated in Vols. 4, 9, 10.

        Regards

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s